Equalising capital gains with income tax would be ‘act of economic self-harm’

Hiking capital gains tax (CGT) as high as 45% is not only a bad idea but a category error, with potential for treble taxation and no indexation, argues Andy Oury, owner partner

Incoming prime minister Andy Burnham is reportedly considering bringing capital gains tax (CGT) into line with income tax - taking the rate from 24% to as much as 45%. Even Sir Tony Blair’s own institute has warned him off, and rightly so.

As someone who has spent a career advising the businesses that would bear this, in my view this is not merely a bad idea but a category error - a confusion about what an asset actually is.

Assets are not income. Income arrives whether you like it or not; a gain only exists if you choose to sell. That single difference is why equalisation fails everywhere it is tried, and why the behavioural response is so brutal.

Your free features:

  • Breaking news and expert analysis
  • Customisable daily newsletters
  • Six free CPD learning modules each year
  • Personalised CPD tracker
  • Top 75 Firms league tables
  • Regulatory changes
  • Hardman’s Tax Data

Sign up to Business & Accountancy Daily

Related Articles
Subscribe